A review of Everything Inside by Edwidge Danticat

Originally published in Compulsive Reader

At a time where immigrant trauma and loss permeates the media, Edwidge Danticat’s book of short stories Everything Inside arrives right on time. The themes of loss and grief run through each of these stories. Danticat is a master of identifying and writing about trauma, especially as it relates to immigrants.

Loss and grief are rooted in a large part of the Haitian diaspora identity and manifests both overtly and covertly throughout these stories. Danticat is meticulous in her writing about Haiti and its people’s complex relationship with the U.S. In each character’s search for a better life, she magnifies the usually unexplored grief that comes with years of generational trauma and migration. With simple, heartfelt, honest storytelling, she transplants her characters into worlds practically any immigrant can identify with, but particularly Caribbean immigrants.

Danticat touches on the suddenness of loss in the story “In the Old Days,” which follows a young teacher who suddenly finds the father she’s never met only to lose him again. After years of silence from her mother about her father’s whereabouts, Nadia finally receives a call from his current wife to visit him on his deathbed in Miami. His wife tells her “his final wish is to spend a few minutes with you.” (41) When she arrives, Nadia is confronted with more than she anticipates – parts of her Haitian culture she was initially denied such as the traditionally intimate way they grieve. There she begins to understand how family separations through migration often result in the loss of culture and the loss of identity. By the time Nadia reaches his deathbed her father is gone and with his wife and friends, she mourns a man she never knew, facing this loss in the confines of a culture she cannot identify with.

One of the collection’s strongest story is “Sunrise Sunset,” which switches points of view between a mother who is in the early stages of dementia and her daughter who is suffering from postpartum depression. The lack of communication and vague assumptions between the women carries the story through to a climactic end, where the mother finally sees her daughter for the woman she really is and vice versa. Relationships between mothers and daughters are notoriously difficult, but relationships between immigrant mothers and second-generation immigrant daughters take on another level of complexity, and Danticat is aware of this when she illuminates this culture clash in this story. “Jeanne has no right to be sad, her mother has often told her. Only Carole has the right to be sad because she has seen and heard terrible things.” (140) Carole’s own difficult upbringing in Haiti leads her to believe her daughter is not a good mother. Jeanne’s lack of understanding of her mother’s past leads her to believe her mother is incapable of love.


Join the Discussion (Comment)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s